Judy And Punch - This Movie Doesn't Hit The Rocks
Dir: Mirrah Foulkes
Judy & Punch is a dark fairy tale-like reinvention of a classic puppet show that engages even if it doesn’t fully succeed. Mr Punch (Herriman) is a renowned puppeteer, an equally renowned drunk and a misogynist – as reflected in the Punch and Judy story. The always excellent Wasikowska is his wife Judy, also a dab hand with the puppets and the recipient of his violent outbursts. All the elements of the classic children’s show are in place – there’s a dog that steals strings of sausages, a ‘gator and a benign policeman, but Foulkes’ film struggles to locate these seaside sideshow elements into a coherent and satisfying whole – even though the film takes place in a land-locked town called “Seaside.”
When Punch’s violent outbursts result in the apparent death and ramshackle burying of his wife, things takes an interesting turn and the movie moves towards becoming a horror-revenge story – but even that is never rendered fully satisfying.
It’s an interesting take on an age-old story, but the brevity of said story leaves this extrapolation full of unsatisfactory holes. It’s like pointing at something but never really finding the depth within it.
Follow us on Twitter @lastwordonearth